Free Roof Inspection

Roof Repair vs. Roof Replacement (Which Do You Need?)

Our roofs often feel indestructible, so when an issue arises, it can be surprising and stressful. If you’ve never had to schedule a roofing service before, you’re probably wondering if you need to get a roof repair or replacement.

Of course, it can be ideal to save money on a roof replacement and go for repairs instead. However, if your roof is in poor condition, you could end up spending more money in the long run if you keep putting off a replacement with repeated repairs.

This homeowners’ guide will help you narrow down what to expect!

Roof Issues That Can Often Be Repaired

If your roof is less than 10 years old, you can usually get by with scheduling repairs if you run into an issue. While there isn’t a guarantee that the following issues are always repairable, you can usually expect that you can avoid a full replacement as long as the majority of your roof is in sound condition.

Roof Leaks

One of the most common roofing issues is a leak. If you have a shingle roof and notice that water is dripping into your home from the ceiling, it’s time to call for repairs.

It’s important to note that if you let a leak go for too long without getting it fixed, it can cause significant damage to your home. In addition, if the water has been seeping in for a while, it could be indicative of a much larger problem with your roof that will require a replacement rather than just repairs.

Moss or Algae Growth

If you have moss or algae growing on your roof, it’s not just an aesthetic issue. This growth can actually cause damage to your shingles by holding moisture against them.

If you catch the issue fast enough, you can usually fix it with a repair. However, if the moss grows significantly, you’ll likely need a full roof replacement.

Missing Shingles

roof repair or replacement shingles

If your roof just has a couple of missing shingles, it’s pretty simple for your roofing contractor to replace them. However, if you have a lot of missing shingles, then the repairs become more significant, and you may be better off with a replacement.

Damaged Flashing

Flashing is the metal or plastic strips that are used to seal the edges of your roof. If this material is damaged, it can lead to leaks.

In most cases, a professional roofing company can repair the flashing without requiring a full roof replacement, as long as the damage isn’t significant.

Light Beams in the Attic

Your roofing contractor should check your attic whenever you schedule a roof inspection. If you or they see light beams coming through your attic ceiling, it means there are holes in your roof.

These holes need to be patched as soon as possible to avoid any water damage. You can often get by with just a repair if the hole isn’t too big.

Clogged Gutters

Your gutters play an important role in protecting your roof. If they become clogged with debris, it can cause water to back up and seep under your shingles.

In most cases, you can clear the gutters yourself and avoid any significant damage. If you don’t feel comfortable clearing out your gutters for any reason, a roof repair contractor can help. Keep in mind that if the water has already caused damage to your roof, you may need further repairs.

man cleaning clogged gutters on roof; roof repair or replacement

4 Signs You Need a Total Roof Replacement

As long as your damage is minimal and your roof is still young, you can usually fare well with repairs. However, if any of the above issues are extreme, you’ll likely need a roof replacement. Additionally, the following four instances are often tell-tale signs you need a full roof replacement.

1) Your Roof Has Reached the End of Its Lifespan

Most asphalt shingle roofs last 15-25 years maximum. If your roof is approaching or at the end of this lifespan, it’s probably time for a replacement rather than just repairs. If your roof is more than 10 years old and you keep needing roof repairs, your contractor will likely recommend a complete roof replacement.

2) Roof Sagging

If you have sagging in your roof, it’s definitely time for a replacement. This means that the wood decking and structure of your roof have deteriorated and can’t support the weight of the shingles and other materials, which puts your entire home at risk. This is an urgent situation, so be sure to call a professional roofer right away if you notice your roof or ceiling sagging.

3) Major Storm Damage

roof repair or replacement tree

If you live in an area that’s prone to hurricanes or other severe storms, your roof may sustain major damage during these events. If the damage is extensive, it will likely require a full replacement rather than just repairs. You may sustain damage from severe weather events, such as:

  • Hail
  • Heavy winds
  • Flying debris
  • Extreme temperatures

This inclement weather can lift or dent your shingles, which can result in roof leaks and water damage. If you sustain storm damage and need a roof replacement, you can file a homeowners insurance claim. If your claim is approved, you can receive reimbursement for your roof replacement.

4) You Want to Sell Your Home, but Your Roof Is Getting Old

A new roof is a major selling point for prospective homebuyers. If you want to increase the value of your home, you may look into getting a roof replacement. If your roof is less than 10 years old, you may not need to worry about your roof. However, if your roof is around 10 years old or more, you may be better off replacing the roof before listing your home for sale.

Rely on a Professional Roofing Contractor for Advice

It can be hard to tell if you need a roof replacement or repairs if you don’t have professional experience. That’s where Tidd’s Roofing comes in. We offer free inspections, and our always-honest team will give you an informed opinion on whether you need a roof repair, replacement, or nothing at all!

Regardless of what your roof needs, our knowledgeable team has the skills to complete your project and set you up for success. We look forward to helping you out! Reach out today to schedule your free inspection.

Recent Articles

roof inspection cost walk

How Much Does a Roof Inspection Cost (+ What’s Included)

7 minutes

Jeremy Tidd

Homeownership often comes with a whole slew of surprises. For example, did you know you should schedule regular roof inspections…

Read More
roof repair or replacement featured

Roof Repair vs. Roof Replacement (Which Do You Need?)

6 minutes

Jeremy Tidd

Our roofs often feel indestructible, so when an issue arises, it can be surprising and stressful. If you've never had…

Read More
how to fix a roof leak featured

How to Find a Roof Leak Step By Step [Picture Guide]

6 minutes

Jeremy Tidd

Drip...💧 Drip...💧 Drip...💧 Just when it seems like nothing has needed fixing in your house for a while, you start…

Read More

The Honest Choice

Get Started
mother and daughter smiling and hugging in home